12/10/2009

Best Of The Decade: The Playlist's Best Films Of 2008

Here are our 2000, 01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 06 and 07 picks.

As the decade came to a close, we have little to complain about. The second-half of the aughts were fantastic and gave us many of our best overall films.

At the box-office, it was nice to see something that wasn't part 4 of a McFranchise. Instead, a piece of smart, thrilling entertainment, Christopher Nolan's "The Dark Knight" took the #1 spot worldwide grossing over more than $1 billion dollars. Even if your opinions of that film are negative (a small minority to be sure), one has to admit this was a step in the right direction. But OK, looking at the rest of the international box-office not so much as films like, "Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull," "Kung Fu Panda" and "Hancock" were the films that dominated.

Still, things were looking optimistic, at the Oscars, Fox Searchlight's persistent, mini-major campaign
which brought two small indie-major films to the Oscar previously ("Juno" and "Little Miss Sunshine") — finally paid off as Danny Boyle's vibrant and immensely enjoyable fairytale "Slumdog Millionaire" (reminding the haters that it has a 94% RT score with Top Critics, not the plebeian masses) deservedly took the Best Picture award. Sean Penn was rewarded for his turn in Gus Van Sant's "Milk" and Kate Winslet finally won a Best Actress Oscar for "The Reader" (she was nominated three times before, and five times in total. It wasn't her best work, but it was her first Oscar). And Heath Ledger won the second ever posthumous acting award in Academy history for his riveting turn as the Joker in "The Dark Knight" (perhaps the film wouldn't have been half of what it was without him).

A rather stellar year for film, 2008 — and the last half of the decade, really — gave us tons of unforgettable classics.


10. "The Wrestler"
Just describing "The Wrestler" sounds like a clumsy jumble of clichés. After all, it's got a down-on-his luck, drug-addled former athlete (a hypnotic Mickey Rourke) who wants to reconnect with his daughter (Rachel Evan Wood) and marry the stripper-with-a-heart-of-gold he covets (Marisa Tomei), all while vying for a return to his former glory. But Darren Aronofsky, taking a documentary approach that wouldn't be out of place on ESPN, captures all the emotion, unexpected comedy and character that lies in between the banalities, signaling a new and brave direction in his filmmaking that brings the story to fully formed life. And at the center is Rourke giving a tour de force performance that seemed to parallel his own career. Raw, modest and austere, his soulful, naked performance blurs reality and fiction in entirely riveting and uncomfortable new ways.

9. "The Edge Of Heaven"
A profoundly entrancing meditation on kismet, chance occurrence, and the capacity for human forgiveness, three seemingly disparate Turkish and German families (Nurgül Yeşilçay, Baki Davrak, and noted Fassbinder actress Hanna Schygulla among them), spanning a few generations, are touched by death and intercede through fate in this Kieslowski-esque- drama by noted director German/Turkish director Fatih Akin. Travel and migration being a major theme in all of Akin's work, characters journey back and forth between the two countries, but any of the-universe-is-all-interconnected conceits are subdued and told in three elliptic vignettes that overlap softly like a dissolve. It's a resonantly compassionate and intricate quilt handcrafted by an intelligent and thought-provoking filmmaker.

8. "A Christmas Tale"
Arnaund Desplechin's "A Christmas Tale" runs down the most rote and well-worn Christmas movie formulas: a family is brought together for the holidays; the matriarch is terminally ill; there's a whole bunch of skeletons in the closet (unrequited love, implacable, long-standing feuds, etc). In lesser hands, this could have been a French "Family Stone." Instead, Desplechin — ironically influenced by "The Royal Tenenbaums" but exceeding it by miles — has woven a novelistic little gem of a movie, odd and oddly moving filled with prickly and vindictive characters giving us a much rawer, and honest view of family life. Stacking the deck with almost all of France's renowned stars (among them Catherine Deneuve as the matriarch and Mathieu Amalric, more villainous than he was in Bond, as the asshole son) and subtle stylistic flourishes (Iris ins, etc.), the movie is acidic, yet eventually, warm and rewarding and a future classic for discerning film lovers who enjoy some bite in their holiday cheer.

7. "Ballast"
Lance Hammer's self-distributed this stark, raw, deeply rich and emotional ravaged tale of a fragmented African American family in a poverty-stricken Memphis delta. Mostly unknown actor Michael Smith Sr. gives an outstandingly inward, yet profoundly projecting performance as a twin quietly devastated by the suicide of his brother who has lost the will to live, yet has to attempt to guide and mentor his troublesome nephew and desperately lost sister-in-law. Pathologically unsentimenta, often bleak and unnervingly spare — with the only moments of music being diegetic sound — the fractured poetry of the austere picture is viscerally gut-wrenching.

6. "Happy-Go-Lucky"
Sally Hawkins gives a fizzy tour-de-force performance as Poppy, a character filled with such bubbly levity she would float off the ground, if she weren’t so grounded by the realities of the world around her. Eddie Marsan is as heartbreaking as he is terrifying as Scott, the tightly wound, paranoid, angry driving instructor whose ill will is no match for Poppy’s eternally sunshiney attitude. The dialectic forces of these two actors’ opposing performances explode in the small confines of the car, and director Mike Leigh uses the jumping off point of Poppy’s always-up demeanor to explore some of humanity’s darker and more interesting moments. Some of Leigh's greatest work in years and bolstered by two of the best performances of the year in Hawkins and Marsan. To write off this film as aggressively ebullient is deeply shortsighted.

5. "Silent Light"
A transcendent and slow-moving tale of adultery set amongst deeply religious Mennonites faced with a personally fractured morality, "Silent Light" is luminously shot and practically a religious experience in itself. Mexican arthouse director Carlos Reygadas' third feature film features all unknown, untrained actors, a meditative and quiet, Terrence Malick-ian tenor, breathtaking, patient visuals and a stunning conclusion that is utterly radiant. Spoken entirely in Plautdietsch, the language of the Prussian Mennonites, this bewitching story of a married man who falls in love with another woman in a small community has not been widely-seen, but it's worth the effort to track down this heavenly piece of cinema endorsed by Martin Scorsese and given award props at Cannes.

4. "4 Months, 3 Weeks & 2 Days"
As an abortion-drama, '4 Months' is the first of its kind, but manages not to skimp on either side of the description. Directed by Cristian Mungiu, this raw-nerve and unflinchingly told picture takes place in the late-80s Communist Romania, and follows a pair of college students (Anamaria Marinca and Laura Vasiliu), one of which needs an abortion dangerously far into her pregnancy. The harrowing chronicle becomes extra potent by being told through the eyes of the friend trying to assist the matter who pays her own heavy psychic toll. As desperation sets in, a roughhewn handheld style not dissimilar from Paul Greengrass' docu-drama feel heightens the tension and immediacy of the girls' situation. Fortunately never falling into the traps of an "issue film," after the most brutal moments are over (and some of it is hard to watch), the film lets you reflect on the disquieting and disturbing acts that have followed.

3. "I've Loved You So Long"
Just thinking of this movie makes us want to quietly weep in a corner. A soulful and extremely moving portrait of the seemingly limitless and incontestable bonds of sibling love, the ugliness of family dark secrets and the hope of personal rebirth, writer Philippe Claudel's directorial debut is anchored by an arresting (and criminally overlooked by Oscar) performance of Kristin Scott Thomas. She plays a drained-of-life woman just released from prison after 15 years for the murder of her six-year-old son. After the family has denounced her, the only one waiting for her is the loving younger sister, Lea, terrifically played with tenderness and empathy by Elsa Zylberstein. Forgiveness and self-absolution in the picture is an arduous and painful cross to bear and 'Loved You So Long' is one of decade's most emotionally wrenching films made about family.

2. "Reprise"
A vibrantly alive and magnetic ode to youth, a passionate chronicle of friendship and the manic energy of a restless mind, "Reprise," struck a chord and never left. Some called this dynamically visualized tale of two competitive best friends (Anders Danielsen Lie and Espen Klouman-Høiner) with literary aspirations and their chronicles of love, loss and mental illness, "Charlie Kaufman-esque," but that's actually banal and fairly reductive. The film does traverse in concepts of fluid time, but the electrical human energy, Bergman-esque contemplation and kinetic zeal is distinctly its own work. A startlingly affecting feature-length directorial debut by Norwegian filmmaker Joachim Trier (born in Denmark), now the big question on our mind is what is he doing next and why hasn't Hollywood, or some smart producer, swooped down on this preternaturally gifted filmmaker to direct an ambitious new project? Perhaps he's far too good for them all. We can only hope another work arrives soon.

1. "Che"
Steven Soderbergh's two part epic is not going to win any points for politics, as it jumps around Che Guevara's life quite liberally and tiptoes around his more serious discretionary acts. However, it does not lionize the man either. Soderbergh takes his coolly proficient scalpel to instead illustrate the anatomy of
a revolutionary, a field leader, and a man capable of great change, who was intrigued with the verbal exchanges in the middle of sieges, the physical steps taken between two points, the hairsbreadth between being the leader of your people and being a victim of unmanaged hubris. Soderbergh benefits from a go-for-broke performance by Benicio del Toro as the political game-changer, and he presents an intense and typically focused characterization that helps create a full picture of a man we might not want to befriend or vilify, but one we desperately want to know.

Honorable Mention:
It really pains us how many great films we had to leave off this list. Number one in that category is perhaps French-Tunisian director Abdel Kechiches' sprawling, roving cinema verite family restaurant drama "Secret Of the Grain." Other strong films that unfortunately could not make the cut, but we still wish to pay recognition to include, Guy Maddin's drunken, wintry and hilarious docu-fantasia, "My Winnipeg," Kelly Reichardt's micro-minimalist poverty tale, "Wendy & Lucy" which suffers from zero plot, but boasts a devastating performance by Michelle Williams; Hou Hsiao-hsien's meandering, but touching, "Flight of the Red Balloon"; still-going at 79 years of age, French New Wave stalwart, Claude Chabrol's deliciously sardonic, "A Girl Cut In Two," featuring excellent performances by Ludivine Sagnier and François Berléand; Danny Boyle's kinetic and celebratory fairy-tale, "Slumdog Millionaire," Gus Van Sant's fourth experimental film in a row, the skate-park teen drama, "Paranoid Park" featuring lovely lensing by the great Christopher Doyle; the German-made Jewish Holocaust prisoners story, "The Counterfeiters" and Claude Miller's absorbing WWII family drama, "A Secret," including an excellent performance by Cécile De France who Clint Eastwood recently tapped for his near-death experiences film, "Hereafter." Also quite amazing is Steve McQueen's IRA hunger-strike drama, "Hunger" featuring an amazing performance by Michael Fassbender.
Other films we appreciate are Martin McDonagh's feature-length directorial debut, the hit-man comedy, "In Bruges" (someone please figure out how to adapt his amazing play "The Pillowman," we elect someone like Bong Joon-Ho or Park Chan-Wook), the Swedish tender-vampire film, "Let The Right One In," "Waltz With Bashir," Harmony Korine's most successful feature film, the dreamy and melancholy, "Mister Lonely,"the under appreciated (at least in the U.S.), Palme d'Or winner, "The Class," by director Laurent Cantet, Thom McCarthy's simple, but effective sophomore picture, "The Visitor," David Gordon Green's Altman-eseque, and surprisingly funny drama, "Snow Angels," David Mamet's mixed-martial arts drama, "Redbelt," Charlie Kaufman's swirl-headed and dour dream, "Synecdoche, New York" and enjoyable entertainment like, "Wall-E" and "The Dark Knight." — Gabe Toro, Drew Taylor, Katie Walsh & RP.

40 comments:

Anonymous said...

Che? Seriously? That's a joke, right?

The Playlist said...

A you a joke?

Spencer Martin said...

Spot on with "Reprise"

James said...

I have to admit I haven't seen any of these other than The Wrestler.

Max said...

I haven't really seen any of these, expect the ones on your honorable mention list. To me, but I'm incredibly biased, The Dark Knight hands down was the best of 2008. Thank you for at least giving Let the Right One In an honorable mention. That's my new favorite vampire movie.

Movies on this list I've been meaning to see (and perhaps will be able to over the holiday season): The Wrestler, I've Loved You So Long, and Che. Maybe then I can actually compare these to the epic that is TDK.

I think Slumdog should have been on the actual list instead of just honorable mention. That was a movie that really lived up to the hype around it, at least for me.

Anonymous said...

I couldn't stand happy go lucky.

Sally Hawkins character made me sick. I couldn't stand being around someone like that in real life, and it was enough seeing her on screen for an hour and a half.

Only saving grace of that movie was the driving instructor. He was great.

Lora Grillo said...

Am not ashamed (maybe a little) to admit I was so scared by Eddie Marsan in Happy Go Lucky, that i had to watch the film in fast forward so I knew the ending before I could relax enough to watch the actual film.

Katie Walsh said...

I went into Happy-Go-Lucky fully expecting to hate it ("so she's just really happy?"), and my sister can't stand the movie, but Sally Hawkins manages to be just kooky enough but also grounded and realistic in her character. The last scene between her and Eddie Marsan is stunning- he is amazingly scary.

The Playlist said...

The first 20 minutes is a bit of a test of wills, I thought I was going to beat the shit out of the old woman next to me just to get out frustration, but the film is much, much more than those 20 minutes, it moves on from that tone and set-up and is funny, sad and moving in equal measure.

Anonymous said...

slumdog millionaire started off good but then just become the worst love story of all time. i liked the dancing the best. more dancing please, india.

Nick Duval said...

I hated both "Snow Angels" and "Redbelt." I have yet to see Che Part 2, but Part 1 was excellently shot and well acted. Props for "Hunger" and "The Wrestler," as well as "Waltz With Bashir," "Synecdoche, New York," and "Happy-Go-Lucky." "Milk" and "Gomorrah" are definitely missing from your list, and I might be in the Playlist following minority, but I think you omitted "Doubt" and "Rachel Getting Married" (the former was very well reviewed here, the latter was called overrated, which in my opinion is untrue). And last but not least, I liked "I've Loved You So Long" and agree that Kristen Scott-Thomas was snubbed, but the movie was vehemently heavy-handed in the final scene. I know the thundering that will get me, but I stand true.

Mike said...

GRR. no mention of Israeli film Beaufort. It was intense and beautiful. (although perhaps a mixup, it was released in Israel 2007, and US 2008. still, was not mention on 2007 list either). If you have not checked it out, you must ASAP.

The Playlist said...

Gomorrah is technically a 2009 film (and it's also vastly overrated).

Anonymous said...

10. Let the Right One In
9. WALL-E
8. Blindness
7. Pineapple Express
6. Slumdog Millionaire
5. Gran Torino
4. Changeling
3. Frozen River
2. The Dark Knight
1. Milk

your mom said...

|"Let The Right One in" is not only the best film of 2008, but the best film of the decade!

Che????? puh - lease!!

Alex said...

Waltz with Bashir is my personal number one.

The Dark Knight and Milk are tied for most overrated film of the year, and the latter is justly not on the list (by-the-book-as-by-the-book-gets biopics don't deserve accolades, nor do turgid, overwrought action films with one good performance). Turns out what a film studio markets as edgy probably is not edgy.

Karl said...

thank christ someone finally made a Top 10 of 2008 list without "The Dark Knight" on it.

Lock said...

If it wasn't for the cheesiness at the end (the surveillance spiel and the boat scenario), the Dark Knight would have been much better. Anyhoo, I'm just a little disappointed Let the Right One In didn't get more love.

notanotherblog said...

Rachel Getting Married
In Bruges
Ballast
The Wrestler
The Dark Knight (sorry)
Slumdog Millionaire
Synecdoche, New York
Vicky Christina Barcelona

Hunger and Hurt Locker are 2009 because my life sucks.

Gabe Toro said...

Sally Hawkins is so fucking wifeable in "Happy Go Lucky," I totally don't get what you guys are saying there.

En ra ha.

rich said...

I'm stunned that nobody has mentioned "Revanche", Gotz Spielmann's astonishingly tense genre-bender, or Olivier Assayas' gorgeous "Summer Hours". Both of these would easily make their way to the top of my best-of-the-decade list.

Are we saving these for 2009?

The Playlist said...

Gabe, I'm not sure what that means exactly, but En Rah Ha, indeed! He's genius.

Rich, can i borrow your time machine because Summer Hours and Revanche are unquestionably 2009.

PPl, if you haven't seen half these films, you need to stop watching Cinemax, broaden your horizons and get out more.

bonzob@earthlink.net said...

Steering people almost entirely towards the most obscure yet critically acclaimed indies of a given year seems more like saying "focus your horizons in this one direction," rather than "broaden" them, no?

Some films I enjoyed that weren't mentioned: Brad Anderson's wonderful travelogue/thriller Transsiberian, Courtney Hunt's stark and honest Frozen River, Bahrani's moving and human Chop Shop, Stuart Gordon's dark satire Stuck, and the best Apatow film Apatow had nothing to do with, Role Models.

Anonymous said...

Your list of the "10 movies nobody has ever heard about" includes 3 entries I'm aware of. So I think you guys are too mainstream.

mel said...

what!! no slumdog in the top 10 now.ur original best of 08 list was better.the only thing right here is che being #1
also me being a huge wrestling fan for over a decade,i can tell the wrestler doesnt deserve so much praise.the business is not as shown in it.

The Playlist said...

Man, these films were all at Cannes. If you're any kind of cinephile, you should have at least heard of them, sheesh.

Anonymous said...

Reprise was terrific and I hope the director is discovered in America more widely, but it also made writing a nationally acclaimed novel look way easier than it probably is.

The Playlist said...

Right, but the novel stuff is treated lightly and quickly on purpose. It's basically a McGuffin to get into other things. It's not about authors now is it.

Anonymous said...

Fair enough.

Brian said...

What about Voy a Explotar? It was released in 2008 and it was incredible. Thanks to your glowing review, I spent most of this year trying to hunt it down and was not disappointed in the least.

Mike said...

reprise was good overall, but the aspects of the film involving the one friend with the buzzed head (forgot his name) and his black haired girlfriend were way too fucking melodramatic and annoying. it really took away from the rest of the movie for me.

The Playlist said...

Uhh you basically jus said, " 'Reprise' was good but the main story sucked."

Why not just say you didn't like the movie and be done with it?

Psyco said...

My best top films of 2008

-the visitor
-Rachel getting married
-happy-go-luckly
-the wrestler
-Revolu. Road
-Frost Nixon

rich said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
rich said...

I say this respectfully and only in my defense, but please take a trip with me in my time machine:

Summer Hours:
http://www.filmlinc.com/archive/nyff/2008/program.html
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0836700/

Revanche:
http://www.criterion.com/films/85
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1173745/


I saw both of these films in 2008 here in New York. While I wish I did, I do not have sufficient VIP status (or time-traveling abilities) to see movies before the rest of the world does.

The Playlist said...

Rich, if you read our rules when this thing first started, respectfully, you would see we went by U.S. release dates of their first actual run in the U.S, as in the beginning of their release, limited or otherwise.

So, yes, you may have seen Summer hours on 1 October 2008 (New York Film Festival). The rest of the world (or the U.S) didn't and (a run at a film festival hardly counts as a U.S. release). 15 May 2009 was its actually, official U.S. release date.

Likewise, you may have seen Revanche early, it did not officially come out in the U.S. until May 1, 2009.

True story.

rich said...

To be sure, I wish I could travel back in time to check out your criteria for a movie's release year before making my initial comment. Fair enough. However, no need to shoot a fellow movie-lover down over such small details.

Having seen them in 2008, I put these films on my best-of list for that year, so I was surprised when I didn't see them on your list, as I've generally agreed with them so far. Bottom line, these movies were terrific, no matter when or where you saw them.

I'll be sure to read your fine print before talking movies here again.

john wall said...

The Wrestler was a really good movie, and I was impressed with Mickey Rourke's acting in the movie.

Anonymous said...

Great list. Also, Let The Right One In is one of the most overrated films of the decade. If it wouldn't have been about vampires, no one would have give a shit.

Anonymous said...

I'm afraid if you thought In Bruges was a comedy you misread the movie. It was badly marketed and you seem to have bought it.

Related Posts with Thumbnails